Two Point Failure: Trials and Tribulations of iPhone Activation

September 22, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

Yesterday I ended my day with a feeling of amused frustration. I received a new iPhone Xs as part of the Apple upgrade program.1 I've used this plan in the past and I've been happy with the results. I had no reason to suspect I'd end up in a long term relationship with Apple support.


The phone failed to complete authorization with Verizon. It rejected my PIN until my authorization was locked. No worries, I thought. I called Verizon and confirmed that my PIN was correct. They also confirmed that the new phone was indeed activated. Yet I couldn't get past the activation screen. Then the line went dead.

Apple Care

Verizon had accepted the new phone and dutifully switched my service to the new device. The problem was that the new device would not proceed past the activation screen and now I could not make or receive calls.2

So I pivoted and went for Apple Support. How do I make a Genius Bar appointment now? Not the Store app. Let's try the Apple support app. Nope. Let's try this link on the Apple page to start a chat. Verified business chat is a thing Apple is excited about so this will be good, right? Woefully wrong.

Give them a call

The Apple iMessage chat is slow. This may be an actual human I'm texting but they clearly have a lot of more important things going on. Eventually they understand the problem and tell me that I must go into an Apple store for support. They also inform me that I can not make an appointment online for my problem but instead must call Apple support. Once again I remind them that my $1500 super computer can no longer make or receive phone calls. They "escalate" the chat. I repeat this comedy routine again with the next guy.


Eventually my wife arrives with her functioning phone and I call Apple support. This is modestly more productive.

The Apple phone support guy is friendly and seems to want to help. He confirms that I'm not the only customer with this problem and calls Verizon tech support. We both wait on hold until we are routed to someone that understands the cause and effect.

Let's Talk

Verizon confirms that "thousands" of customers are unable to activate new Apple devices. We try a hard reset of my new Xs. No luck. Our only option is to wait. He suggests I wait until the following day and try again. He re-activates my old iPhone. We part ways on friendly terms and feel like we bonded over a shared frustration with computers.

Today was part two.

I started with a call to Verizon customer support. After giving them a few moments to read the case I requested that they escalate my call to technical support as an open ticket. Verizon technical support is very pleasant and now they call Apple to initiate another 3-way troubleshooting call. After a few more SIM card swaps, hard resets, reference checks on the serial number, IMEI, and SIM IDs we end amicably but still dissapointed.

I've been "escalated" to Apple engineering to resolve whatever issue is preventing authentication. I can expect a call.

Here's what I've learned:

  1. Many people are having issues activating phones purchased from Apple and activated through existing Verizon accounts.
  2. Verizon will switch you service to a non-functioning phone
  3. You can't make Genius bar appointments for a phone that will not activate
  4. You can not use iMessage chat with Apple for pretty much anything
  5. Having another phone around is crucial
  6. Verizon and Apple will both join conference calls to help troubleshoot
  7. Having Verizon and Apple on the same call does not double the productivity
  8. You will need your IMEI, serial number, CCID, and SIM card ID ready
  9. Always ask to be transfered to Verizon technical support, not customer support. Technical support is top-notch
  10. You reset an iPhone Xs by plugging it into iTunes, tapping the up volume then down volume, then holding the lock button

I've spent four hours between text chat, phone calls with Verizon, and phone calls with Apple. Most of it has been pleasant. At these new price points, I'd like for Apple to raise their bar for support. Apple's addition of iMessage chat is a net negative for me. Their removal of online scheduling of store appointments is also a downgrade in service.

  1. Silver 512 GB model 

  2. I'm no Millennial but even I realize a landline is a general waste of money. Until yesterday.  


Older articles

  1. Jupyter Notebooks at Netflix

    September 10, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I love this Netflix blog post about how they use Jupyter notebooks.

    I’m not an programmer but I do play one at work and I’m partial to using notebooks when I explore. Part of my day job is to develop the system architecture for a long term engineering ...

  2. Anki Flashcards

    September 09, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I’ll admit, I’m terrible at rote memorization. I always have been, which is weird for someone that became a chemist. Often chemistry is approached by pre-med students as another flashcard topic, and this definitely works for many people.

    If you are someone that uses flashcards then this Anki ...

  3. Valve explains 'progress' toward a new Steam Store content policy

    September 06, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    From Engadget

    As far as the games that are (or will be) allowed, the plan is for developers of games with violent or sexual content to write their own description that includes context of how the material appears.

    I may be wrong, but I think Valve will regret this model ...

  4. The Missed Opportunity of Shelf Apps on iOS

    September 03, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    With iOS 12 right around the corner, I'm feeling a little let down by the variety and power of "shelf" apps on iOS 11. Apple provided us with a new model to move data between apps and it was a great start. One of my favorite features of drag ...

  5. Student Discounts on DEVONthink

    August 23, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    As a college student in the 90's I was relieved to get a computer. When I finished college all of my documents fit on about three floppy disks. I think school today requires a bit more knowledge management and I can't recommend the Devontech products enough. Get 40 ...

  6. Mastodon: Now I've Got Two Problems

    August 23, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    That didn't take long. Yesterday I shared my Mastodon address as an alternative to following a ghost on Twitter. Within hours I got a link (by email) explaining some weirdness connecting with people I knew on other instances of Mastodon.

    In what can only be called a "double turns-out ...

  7. Mastodon as a Twitter Alternative

    August 22, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Just go read these articles by Joe:

    Social Technical-Debt

    First Time Tooter, Long Time Tweeter

    I'm skeptical that anyting can or should replace Twitter. I don't think we are ready for this type of interaction but I'd love to be wrong. I miss a lot of my ...

  8. Drafts for Mac Status Update

    August 22, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Drafts for Mac Status Update:

    What can Drafts for Mac do?

    The initial version of Drafts for Mac will support most of the same draft capture, editing and organization features of Drafts 5 on iOS and all drafts, tags, workspaces, versions, etc. will sync between versions.

    The editor will support ...

  9. Anti-SLAPP Suit After Trying To Punish Paper For Exposing Its Redaction Failure

    August 14, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    What was delivered to the Sun Sentinel by the district had black redaction bars covering two-thirds of the document. Unfortunately, the redactions were merely cosmetic. Anyone with a copy of the PDF could select the "redacted" text in the PDF and paste it into a text editor to see what ...