The Difference of Good Ink on the iPad Pro

February 03, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

I use my 10.5" iPad Pro every day for taking notes. I greatly prefer to hand-write my notes using the Apple Pencil. This allows me to capture ideas and questions in the margins as well as detailed drawings and diagrams in the main body. It's fantastic. But, unlike plain text, this is one area where the app makes all the difference.

Many iPad note apps support the Apple Pencil and implement some sort of inking system with line coloring and thickness adjustments. Very few nail the actual feel of pen on paper though. Like any pen collector, I've become very picky about the performance of the ink in most iPad apps.

Here are my very strong opinions on the ink from some of the best free-writing note apps.

GoodNotes

The ink in GoodNotes feels the closest to actual pen on paper. The line keeps up with the tip of the pencil regardless of how fast I move it. There's no pressure responsiveness in GoodNotes but it doesn't feel like it needs it. The middle line thickness almost always looks good.

Nebo

Nebo has really excellent handwriting ink.

The fast ink performance of Nebo keeps up with the Apple Pencil and makes it feel very natural. It's one of the best inking apps for handwriting.

Procreate

Nothing beats Procreate for customizability and performance. It's the most natural and "real" ink I've used on the iPad. Even the pencil lead, with it's rough texture and pressure sensitivity feels perfect. Sometimes I just sit and doodle in Procreate because it feels good.

ZoomNotes

ZoomNotes has really nice inking speed that keeps up with the Apple Pencil. There are a lot of convenient options for tuning the ink settings and saving them as preferences. The app itself is a bit of a UI mess but I give it high marks in the ink category.

Sketches Pro

Sketches Pro is a nice general drawing app but it can be slow when drawing fast. The ink can't keep up with fast hand movements while doing rough sketches.

Sketches Pro

Linea

The simplicity of Linea can be a relief. The ink is incredibly fast and drawing feels smooth. It's a fun doodling app that has lots of potential.

Concepts

Ink in Concepts doesn't really feel natural, but to be fair, it's a vector drawing app. There's a lot of control in Concepts for tweaking the line style but there's just too much smoothing even at the lowest setting. I like Concepts for other things, but it's just not a good writing and doodling app for me.

Notes Plus

The ink in Notes Plus is just too slow to feel natural. I notice the lag and the aggressive line smoothing means I don't even recognize my own handwriting. I like everything else about Notes Plus but I just can't get used to the ink.

Changing the "viscosity" does make the ink feel thicker and stickier but it never feels right. It's a good app marred by bad ink.

Sure, it's just a line of pixels, but the ink in a sketch app matters to me. I use an iPad partly because it's a joy. It should follow the tip of the Apple Pencil as if it was flowing directly from it. It should make me forget that it's a piece of plastic on glass.

There's a special kind of joy that comes with using good tools. I love the feel of a good pen on top-shelf paper. The quality of the tool may not mean much for the quality of the end result but it sure does make the journey more fun.

Older articles

  1. Things I Failed At

    January 28, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    During December I had a lot of time think. That's never a good thing. I ended up with a little project to define my personal values. I want something I can write down and measure myself against. You know, kind of a like a corporate mission statement or values ...

  2. Meeting Templates for GoodNotes

    December 23, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Sometimes I want a blank page. Other times I just need a little mental nudge to keep me on track. That's one of the nice features of GoodNotes for iOS and Mac: It's easy to create new paper templates.

    My use case is pretty simple. I've long ...

  3. The New MindNode 5

    December 17, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I’ll be honest, I hate most mind-mapping apps. A good mapping app does more than just put text on lines. It should make it easy to capture, organize, and then use ideas. MindNode is one of a handful of apps that I can recommend.

    iPad

    The new MindNode is just ...

  4. iThoughts for iOS 11

    September 24, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Not to be outdone this week, iThoughts received a few new iOS 11 features:

    1. Siri integration
    2. Drag and Drop

    Both are nicely demonstrated in the app-maker's video below:

    To use the Siri integration configure your quick capture map.

    Quick Note Setting

    This makes adding new items to an iThoughts inbox very easy ...

  5. iOS Life On the Edge

    September 08, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I feel uncomfortable relying on one technology that has no alternative. This discomfort might come from the fact that I don't have a lot of time to solve the same problems again. But, maybe there's more to it. I simply don't enjoy reinventing the wheel just because ...

  6. Taskmator 3.7 Update

    August 11, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    The best TaskPaper app for iOS was updated several times this summer and continues to improve and squash bugs. For the unfamiliar, Taskmator came out shortly after the death of the official TaskPaper iOS app. It steadily fixed long-standing bugs in the original app but then expanded with features like ...

  7. Taking Notes with Nebo on an iPad

    August 02, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    This blog post is a hand crafted artisanal production. well, its hand crafted at least. That's because I wrote it by hand, long-form in the iPad app MyScript Nebo,

    Writing is good

    Nebo works with the Apple Pencil to convert hand writing into text. It's one of the best digital handwriting ...

  8. Trello Note Archive [Link]

    April 20, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] | ℳ↫

    This is a very impressive (and extensively referenced) blog post. I've repeatedly struggled to use Trello for project management. It has never clicked for me. This is a great tutorial for the basic capabilities in Trello but it's also a thoughtful breakdown of an information capture system. I ...

  9. My Text Corpus in 2017

    March 14, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I've long used nvALT and Dropbox to maintain my collection of notes on my Mac. The benefit of this system is that so many iOS applications sync with Dropbox. I can search and edit my large collection of notes almost anywhere that I'm sitting. But 2016 brought some ...