Notability Improvements and a Replacement for GoodNotes

July 05, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

GoodNotes is a terrific app for handwritten notes. I often need a combination of diagrams, text, and plain old doodles for meeting notes. The advantage of GoodNotes has always been its excellent handwriting recognition and export. But, I've switched to Notability since a recent update that adds handwriting recognition on top of Notability’s other more refined features.

Handwriting

The ink system in GoodNotes is subtly better than Notability. It feels a bit smoother and more realistic to me. But the difference is slight and in my use not important enough to ignore the other application differences.

Ink Support

There are plenty of ink variations in Notability for my needs. I try to avoid using too many colors and almost always use the same line thickness.

Text and More

While I love handwriting in GoodNotes it always felt a bit awkward to type text. Notability makes it a lot more natural to jump between the two modes and provides some additional formatting options that actually keep me typing longer.

As with the ink, there are limited text formatting options in Notability but what’s there is easily accessible and covers most of what I want to do. Notability also adds an option to create three favorite formats to quickly apply to text.

Text Formatting

The same features exist on the iPhone and the Mac but the favorites do not sync, which is a bit of let down. Still, the simplicity of having just three favorites is exactly how I work with text formatting in my notes. I don’t want to fiddle, I just want to call attention to some text or create an informative divider in a section.

iPhone Formatting

Simple formatting is the least of what I like about text in Notability. The support for outlines and checklist is excellent and something that is one of the main selling point over GoodNotes. On any of the supported Notability platforms, just select some text and set the format to checklist. Tapping an item crosses it off the list. Tab indents new items and they even support formatted text within checklists.

Check lists on Mac

Number outlines are also well supported in Notability. I find these particularly useful for meeting agendas. I add annotations with the handwriting ink around the outline and later export the entire thing to my note archive in DEVONthink.

There’s a curious option when working with date text in Notability. After typing a date string, it becomes underlined. Tapping or clicking the date reveals surprisingly useful options.

Active Dates

I’d love to see Notability expand on these options to link between dates and calendar events or even allow me to change the date with a calendar picker instead of typing.

Organization and Search

A major difference between Notability and GoodNotes (and many other iOS note apps) is Notability’s global search and three level document organization. Through a combination of folders and dividers I can create a moderately useful note organization. I use “dividers” to separate three top level categories of notes: Home, Work, and Scratch (a.k.a. “Doodles”). Inside each divider I have “groups” that hold notes in Notability. I use groups like projects. Groups can have a user selected highlight color as well as an optional passcode.

None of this matters too much because I don’t use Notability for long term storage and Notability supports global search across all documents. This means I keep running documents in Notability but if I ever need to quickly jump to a location in a given note, I can use search.

Search in Notability is somewhat basic but it has 90% of what I want, including search of handwriting recognition text, search of indexed PDFs, and hit highlighting across documents.

Search

Multi-Document View and Markup

Notability now also supports multi-document view. It’s like split-screen but within the Notability window. This makes working with a reference document (like a PDF) and notes a very nice improvement over using a separate PDF viewer with the iOS split screen mode.

Multiple Documents

GoodNotes and Notability are comparable PDF annotation tools and both are inferior to a dedicated app like PDF Expert. The markup options are limited to the standard ink tools like drawing and highlights. However, the annotation index is helpful and bookmarking is easy.

PDF Markup

My biggest complaint about PDF annotation in Notability is that the “Stickies” are not true PDF annotations. They are really just image objects you can write on top of. Text and drawings are not contained within the sticky. I’d use these a lot more if they worked a little bit better.

Simple annotation in both apps is useful. If I was working on a large reference document and doing a lot of markup, I’d much rather be in an app like Liquid Text or PDF Expert.

Multi-Device Sync

This is an area where Notability is far superior to GoodNotes. Syncing through iCloud in Notability is nearly instant and happens in the background across devices. When I open my iPhone to quickly check on a note, it’s already there. I can add content from my Mac and it’s on all of my devices within seconds without having to launch the apps.

The iPad is the best way to use Notability in my opinion but that doesn’t mean it’s a bad experience on the Mac or iPhone. The Mac app is a full featured note-taking tool with great options for check lists, editing, and audio recordings. It lacks some of the nicer features of the iPad like text extraction from handwriting and saved text styles.

Capture and Export

Notability has a couple of ways to capture from a web page on iOS. The sharing extension works well but is very basic. There’s no option to capture selected text as an annotation on the captured PDF. Even without this, it’s a handy research tool for gathering web clips and annotating them back inside Notability.

Web Capture

There’s also an in-app browser inside Notability. Tap the plus button to add an object and then choose web clip. This opens a browser window. But, as with the Safari sharing option, it’s very basic. In fact, I find this option nearly useless as it captures an image of the website, an only the portion that fits within the view frame.

App Browser Capture

There are three export formats supported by Notability: PDF, RTF, and Notability. I always use PDF. But, if you want to share with another Notability user, use the native format to retain all of the features, including audio recordings. If I was sharing coursework notes with a friend, I’d probably use the Notability format. Most of my export is for long term archive, so I use PDF.

Export

In addition to exporting single documents, Notability also provides support for combining multiple documents into a single export. This is a great way to take a lot of little notes and convert them into a single weekly archive to store in DEVONthink.

Multi Export

Notability also provides an option to combine documents without exporting as well as a quick name editing mode that saves a lot of time over editing one document title at a time.

Conclusion

I’m all in with Notability now. It’s still a close race with GoodNotes but overall I think Notability is an easier app to use. I’d prefer if Notability could extract all of the text from a document without needing to manually select chunks of handwriting. I’m not sure what patent limits this but there are very few apps that have this option, with Nebo being the exception. I simply don’t like the other features of Nebo enough.

Notability | Universal iOS | $10

GoodNotes | Universal iOS | $8

PDF Expert | Universal iOS | $10

Liquid Text | iPad | Free

Nebo | iPad | $6

Older articles

  1. Mr. Reader Actions for Editorial

    January 15, 2014 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Thanks again to Mr. Reader for sponsoring Macdrifter. I really can't say enough good things about this RSS reader for iPad. All of themes for the app look gorgeous and the extensibility is unmatched.

    Mr. Reader comes with some core actions but the action customization is wide open too ...

  2. Taking Action on Feeds with Mr Reader for iPad [Sponsor]

    December 30, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    My thanks to Mr. Reader for sponsoring Macdrifter this week. It's my preferred news reader on any platform, thanks to the elegant design and powerful actions. It also supports a huge variety of RSS aggregation services so it's likely you can start using it today.

  3. Bookmarker Macros for Editorial

    December 28, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    This pair of macros for Editorial brings a whole new level of bookmarking to text files on the iPad. Ever want to bookmark a specific spot in a text file or remember where you left off editing a text file in Editorial? Me too. So, I created this pair of ...

  4. Color on the Retina iPad Mini [Link]

    November 17, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] | ℳ↫

    As always, Anandtech gets into the details where other reviews do not.

    The iPad mini with Retina Display has the same color gamut as the standard iPad mini, which is narrower than the iPad Air and less than the sRGB coverage we normally look for. The biggest issue here is ...

  5. iPad Mini Available Now

    November 12, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Apple finally alleviated the supply constraints on wheelbarrows for moving their cash. The iPad Mini is available now.

  6. Mr. Reader 2.0 Adds New Sync Services [Link]

    June 26, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] | ℳ↫

    Mr. Reader 2.0 is out today and adds a handful of supported sync services.

    • BazQux Reader
    • Feedbin
    • FeedHQ
    • Feedly
    • Feed Wrangler
    • Fever

    It's a great start and just in time for the final death rattle of Google Reader.

  7. Dropbox and Photos: Two iOS Apps

    January 31, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I keep most of my photos archived in an Aperture library. But I also have a good size collection in Dropbox. I'm not likely to move completely to Dropbox for my photo collection. It's much too large and I really like the benefits I get with Aperture. Dropbox ...

  8. The Benefits of Mr. Reader

    January 27, 2013 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Viticci made me switch from Reeder to Mr. reader on iOS with clever tricks and high praise (see the Macstories review as well). But, believe it or not, I didn't switch for the URL scheme support. I switched for the better reading experience.1

    Here's a quick tip ...

  9. 100 Word Review: Handcrafted App

    October 24, 2012 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Shhh. I have a secret. I shop on Etsy occasionally. I'm not crafty by nature. I loathe wicker, cringe at paper-craft and detest all things knit. But I like Etsy. I've found some wonderful pieces of art and great iPhone and iPad accessories. The best experience I've ...