The Last Mile for the iPad

June 23, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

7 years after the iPad release, some of us are still trying to parse out if it is a real computer. I, for one, have given up. Everything is a computer now. Some just have more well defined roles. While I consider my iPad Pro and my MacBook Pro to both be computers, they are different kinds of computers. Here's the Venn diagram of their capabilities in my daily life.1

venn

Steve Jobs once likened the Mac to a truck and iOS to a car. Even with how little he knew of the future of iOS back in 2013, I still think it was a bad analogy.2 If anything iOS is a motorcycle. It's fun, light, and makes you think really hard about what you might need on a road trip.

With the iPad Pro and the changes planned in iOS 11, iOS computing has come very close to replacing my Mac. But close is still not enough for me. I could certainly get by with a motorcycle for 90% of what I use a car for but that last 10% is going to hurt. A drive to work? Sure. No sweat. A trip to Ikea? GTFO.3

The Alpha Computer

The simple fact that iOS still has a screen that directs you to plug into a Mac to recover the device, tells me what Apple thinks of iPad independence.

Here's a funny story.

The very first thing I had to do with my shiny new iPad Pro was plug it into a 2013 MacBook Pro. I was unable to login into iCloud on the new iPad. It just said "Verification Failed." I could login through Safari, but no iCloud settings could connect. After a call to Apple, they suggested a reset of the device THROUGH MY MAC, which did the trick.4 Apparently I got a bum install of iOS at the factory.

I could have visited an Apple Store to do this. Making an appointment is now much easier with the iOS Apple Store app. Prior to that, I would have needed to browse through the Apple website in Safari and entered all of my details in a web form. If you spend much time on iOS, you may already be cringing. Web forms are kryptonite for iPads.

Death By Form

Funny story number two.

About a year ago I sold one house and bought a different house. Living in the future has some major advantages if you "want" to work with banks, realtors, and contractors. For example, you can sign a document on your iPhone while racing back to rescue the Hue bulbs you left in the old spare bedroom. But what you can't do is upload dozens of financial documents from your iPad to your mortgage company's web form. For this, you may need a Mac and a stiff drink.5

The web is still not iOS friendly. It's improving but there's a lot of legacy out. Not enough business is dependent on serving people that don't have a PC or Mac.

It's in Here Somewhere

There was a time when storage was the main reason I needed a Mac. That's still a good argument but only if you really commit to making a lot of excuses for your hoarding. My photo collection on my Synology NAS is about 3 TB. The maximum storage I can get through iCloud is 2 TB. That's annoying but I only have myself to blame. Well, that and all of these high resolution iPhone photos of the inside of my pocket.

When I bought the new iPad Pro, I made sure to get the maximum storage available, which is 500 GB. With file management coming to iOS 11, it looks like I'll be using my iPad even more. 500 GB is not that much space but it will give me room to breath. I look forward to a future when my computer just knows what files I'll need on a plane or when I'm at a conference and the entire city is using the same WiFi network. Until that time, I'll keep most of what I might need stored locally on the device.

But that brings me to a new problem on iOS. Finding what I'm looking for is getting harder. Spotlight is poorly tuned for showing me what I need. In fact, it often thinks I want to download a new mortgage app when I search for my recent mortgage statement. Maybe iOS 11+ will solve this problem. Right now I have 20 years of files, of which, 7 years are pretty vital.

I keep almost every important document encrypted in DEVONthink and sync between devices with Dropbox. By keeping my documents siloed in one app, tagged, and sorted into folders I can usually find what I need pretty quickly. But iOS makes it difficult to work with the files outside of DEVONthink and save changes back. My Mac does this reliably.

Relax. Kick Back

I think it's ironic that the most portable computer I have is the least comfortable to type with while on the couch. I have the Apple Smart Keyboard as well as the Logitech Slim Combo keyboard for the iPad Pro 10.5" and I have no complaints about the key spacing. It really is close enough for me to type at normal speeds. But both of these keyboards work best on a hard flat surface. I do my best Chris Farley impression when I'm trying to type with my iPad on my lap.

I can type more comfortably on my iPhone than I can with my iPad Pro on the couch, in bed, or even just reclined in the backyard. I'm sure there's a good case out there that will solve this problem, but I'd rather see Apple solve it.

The Slim Combo is a nice case but not a very good keyboard. I like the back-lighting of the keys and the key spacing keeps me typing at full throttle. I also like the amount of key travel. Even the Pencil holder is a nice touch. But I really have to say that the kickstand stinks. It's functional but a pain to use. The keyboard easily disconnects when I don't want it to. Finally, the case is pretty thick. It takes the svelte and elegant iPad and turns it into a swollen awkward piece of plastic.

Slim Combo

The Pencil Blew it Right

Looking back that the Venn diagram above, there's a little sliver of functionality for the iPad that my Mac just can't touch.6 The Pencil on the iPad Pro is a terrific device. The responsiveness makes it feel like writing on a whiteboard. The flexibility in iOS means it's not just for drawing or writing.

Apps like Linea and Paper are a lot of fun with the Pencil. I like to doodle and draw cartoons. The responsiveness of the Pencil and new iPad Pro makes me want to use them instead of paper and pen, which I never thought was possible.

I tried to take meeting notes on the 12.9" iPad Pro with the app Nebo. Nebo does live conversion of handwritten notes to typed text but it also provides a way to combine drawn diagrams in-line. The 12.9" iPad Pro was a distraction during meetings. It was just so large that I think it became a focus of attention. The 10.5" iPad seems much acceptable. Because I'm actively writing with iPad flat on the desk with a Pencil, there's no chance people will think I'm browsing email either.

I've only used it in a few meetings so far, but the acceptance is high. It also makes it a lot easier to send out meeting notes when compared to transcribing notes on paper.

The Last Mile

Dreaming about the future, I think Apple can bring the iPad close to parity with the Mac.7 I don't have as many complaints as some. I don't need USB connections. I can scan from my Fujitsu ScanSnap over WiFi just fine.

ScanSnap

I also think a better keyboard is inevitable, but voice and handwriting recognition is getting dramatically better. I wrote a lot of this post in Drafts for iOS using nothing but the dictation input. It's fine for a first draft while I'm sitting alone at home.

Drafts Dictation

But Apple has a blind spot that I think might mean the iPad never has parity with the Mac. The App Store just doesn't encourage big powerful app development.

The price point on the iOS App Store is too low for many indie developers to succeed. I look at the most powerful apps I use and they come from a handful of companies dedicated to craft but supported by Mac revenue. Omnigraffle, OmniFocus, and OmniOutliner are great. But there are few competitors in this space that can reach the same level of quality and still make a profit. I suspect that in an iOS-only world these apps would end.

Transmit and Coda by Panic are top-tier software, but even they seem to be struggling to justify their existence.

This doesn't mean that great apps don't still get released on iOS. They just don't keep getting supported. My favorite text editors, the best personal databases, the variety of bookmark managers. They might keep rolling out, but the majority aren't actively developed.

From the outside, it looks like the Mac is a platform to build a business on and iOS is the place to sell your passion products. I'm not sure what Apple can do to change this. The roadblocks were built when Apple first set their app price points at the bottom. Most users think a dollar is too much for anything on iOS, but anything short of $20 is probably not sustainable for a small developer.

I feel like Apple will take us almost to our destination by making insanely great iPad hardware with the best operating system money can buy. Unfortunately I fear that we will be lacking the vibrant and diverse software to get us that last mile where we don't just wish we had a Mac.


  1. Perhaps the least useful visualization for making an argument. It's also worth noting that creating a high quality JPEG of an OmniGraffle image without the canvas is a complete pain on iOS. 

  2. Yes, yes. He was actually talking about tablets specifically. But at this moment in computer history an iPhone 7 Plus looks pretty darn close to an iPad Mini. 

  3. Yes, you can pay Ikea to deliver most things to your house. You're just changing who needs the car for your delivery. Don't be pedantic. 

  4. First they suggested I reset my iCloud password to "see if that fixed it." Politely suggested that it would be like removing all of my skin to deal with a case of Eczema.  

  5. The bourbon isn't a requirement but it helps. 

  6. Have I mentioned how much I like dad jokes? 

  7. I still had to search for how to type a lower case letter at the start of a sentence in iOS. If you have an external keyboard, it's nearly impossible. Here's a hint: there's no way to do it without changing the global keyboard settings. That's one point for the Selectric fans out there. 

tags
iOS

Older articles

  1. The New iPad Pro Screen

    June 22, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I now own a 10.5" iPad Pro. I've occasionally used the 12.9" first generation iPad Pro reserved mostly for my kid. The 12.9" is glorious to look at but it was just too big to be my every day device. As expected, the 10.5" is ...

  2. Apple Silicon and Machine Learning [Link]

    June 13, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] | ℳ↫

    Great article from Jean-Louis Gassée

    Let’s indulge in a bit of speculation.

    Tentatively dubbed Apple Neural Engine (ANE), this hypothetical chip fits well with Apple’s tradition of designing hardware for its software, following Alan Kay’s edict: “People who are really serious about software should make their own ...

  3. Picking a Device Storage Size

    June 10, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I used to carefully pick the perfect capacity size of each new Apple device I'd buy. With everything syncing between devices, photos getting larger and videos getting longer, I now just go with the largest size I can get.

    This is my current iPhone.

    Almost Full

    Spending time juggling what data ...

  4. The iPad 10.5 Smart Keyboard Size

    June 10, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Apple did not lie about the size of the iPad Pro 10.5 Smart Keyboard size. It is very close to a full size keyboard. Here it is in comparison to a keyboard on a Macbook Pro 15".

    Smart Keyboard

    Here's a comparison of the new Logitech Slim Keyboard Case

    Logitech

    The ...

  5. DEVONthink and Scanner Pro Together

    June 02, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    DEVONthink and Scanner Pro for iOS have both been updated in the last week to provide better integration between the two apps. Now Scanner Pro shows DEVONthink prominently as a destination app for saving scans.

    The implementation isn't ideal though. It's only marginally better than using the "Open ...

  6. iThoughts Update Supports Document Providers

    April 13, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    iThoughts for iOS has a nice update this week that adds support for document providers. Now I can store my planning maps inside DEVONthink along with the rest of my project data and still open them from within iThoughts for editing.

    Document Providers

    I like the Smart Folder I have on my ...

  7. Tails for iOS

    April 13, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    My good friend and amazing designer Erik Hess did something. He made a sticker pack just because he loves Tomcats. I think they are beautiful. I'd imagine if you like aircraft, this would be right up your alley. It's two bucks which like 1/19,000,000 of ...

  8. Is Slack Secure Enough

    March 31, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I sure do like Slack. It's a hugely convenient service that I actually pay for.1 Many of my best friends are on Slack and it's a continuous source of enjoyment and intelligent discussions for me. But I use it less now because I can't trust its ...

  9. On That Workflow Acquistion

    March 23, 2017 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I first heard about it on Slack and then on Macstories.1 Apple acquired the venerable Workflow app for iOS. From Apple's statement to Techcrunch:

    “The Workflow app was selected for an Apple Design Award in 2015 because of its outstanding use of iOS accessibility features, in particular an ...